Qualifying the best data warehouse vendor.
by Robin Jessani
You've got an opportunity and you want to seize it quickly. You need a simplified, high-performance decision support solution that can be
implemented speedily, easily and without breaking your budget—a solution that doesn't require a lot of your resources to set up or administer
and will appeal to your users and to your management.
You don't want to go through a lengthy evaluation process, but you want to make sure that you are getting the best solution for your money.
Accept no compromises—look for a solution that can fulfill your needs for high performance and ease of implementation at the right price.
It's the vendors' goal to convince you that they have superior technology and performance and are the best choice for you. Taking the time to
do a little detective work will help you identify the solution that truly delivers the highest value for your investment.
Look for solutions that do not require trade-offs for one dimension over another. While simplicity, ease and price are primary considerations
in your purchase decision, you don't want to compromise on other solution characteristics either. For example, you can have unbelievable
performance, but if it is at the expense of availability or another dimension, is it worth it? Although solutions may have common tasks and
produce common results, they will vary in how they accomplish those tasks, in what timeframe and at what cost.
Finding a solution that "has it all" may seem daunting, but a lot of the preliminary analysis has been done for you. You can simplify your
selection process tremendously by consulting with people who are knowledgeable and experienced. Industry analysts perform independent comparisons
of vendors and can provide objective opinions of different solutions. Their reports depict vendor positioning measured against a common set of
criteria and can be helpful in assessing the technology and performance of competing solutions.
| Find the best high-performance solution |
|
A few key steps will help you find the best high-performance solution for your organization:
| > |
Consult with industry analysts.
|
| > |
Ask for and meet with customer references.
|
| > |
Narrow the search by asking your top 10 questions.
|
| > |
Measure performance based on common ground rules.
|
| > |
Consider present and future needs.
|
| > |
Project overall value for the solution, not just cost.
|
|
|
Likewise, customer references are a great source of information that provide incredible insight into vendor capabilities and working
relationships. Ask the vendor to arrange for you to speak with some of its customers that mirror your situation—where you are today and
where you'd like to be in the future. These organizations not only have insights into choosing a vendor for a project, they have also lived
through decision support evolution and can tell you whether the vendor will meet your ongoing needs.
This background work gives you a good starting point, but you will still want to do additional primary research. Issuing a request for
information to all the vendors can help you quickly whittle down your list. For example, your top 10 questions, such as "Are you certified
with our chosen extract, transform and load [ETL] and online analytical processing [OLAP] tools?" may knock several contenders out of the
running.
| enlarge |
|
This Magic Quadrant graphic was published by Gartner, Inc. as part of a larger research note and should be evaluated in
the context of the entire report. The Gartner report is available upon request from Teradata.
|
|
The Magic Quadrant is copyrighted 8/1/06 by Gartner, Inc. and is reused with permission. Gartner, Inc.'s permission to
print or reference its Magic Quadrant should not be deemed to be an endorsement of any company or product depicted in
the quadrant. The Magic Quadrant is Gartner, Inc.'s opinion and is an analytical representation of a marketplace at
and for a specific time period. It measures vendors against Gartner, Inc.-defined criteria for a marketplace. The
positioning of vendors within a Magic Quadrant is based on the complex interplay of many factors. Gartner, Inc. does
not advise enterprises to select only those firms in the Leaders segment. In some situations, firms in the Visionary,
Challenger, or Niche Player segments may be the right match for an enterprise's requirements. Well-informed vendor
selection decisions should rely on more than a Magic Quadrant. Gartner, Inc. research is intended to be one of many
information sources including other published information and direct analyst interaction. Gartner, Inc. expressly
disclaims all warranties, express or implied of fitness of this research for a particular purpose.
|
|
Taking steps
With your short list established, you can compare and validate performance claims with a benchmark or a performance analysis. When taking this
step, think about how the solution will meet your users' needs. For example, consider:
|
How many concurrent users and queries are likely to run?
|
|
Will the queries vary in prioritization?
|
|
Are some queries response-time-sensitive?
|
|
Can you load data while running queries?
|
|
How often do your queries run (multiple times a day, once a day, once a month, etc.)?
|
Asking—and answering—questions such as these will give you a way to assess performance across vendors. Setting up common ground rules based
on your specific requirements will give you confidence when measuring performance and other dimensions across solutions.
Once performance assessments are understood, consider projected solution value by comparing the price of the solution relative to the business
results it delivers. Keep in mind that a lower acquisition price doesn't mean that a solution will be a better deal. Value cannot be measured
on price alone—but rather by the value to the organization, based on meeting the performance goals for the users and applications relative to
the price paid.
Some vendors advertise single-purpose solutions at relatively low price points, supporting one application and a handful of concurrent users.
Others offer multipurpose decision support solutions at competitive price points, capable of supporting several applications and many users.
They provide the flexibility that single-focus solutions can't.
In fact, many companies start small—often with a single application area. By looking ahead, plans for growth can be factored into your
decision-making criteria.
Think about your cell phone and how rapidly changing technology is affecting feature adoption. You can now watch short videos, send and
receive e-mail, or listen to music with your cell phone. While you may not have intended to use these capabilities, they are available to you.
As you experiment with them your usage grows. The same is true with data warehousing. In decision support, while the extended capabilities of
multi-purpose solutions may seem beyond your scope right now, they do not affect your daily operations and you just may recognize a need for
them in the very near future.
Why settle?
Many vendors are messaging simple, fast and affordable data warehouse solutions. Why settle for single-purpose solutions when you can get
high-performance solutions at similar price points? In today's unpredictable and ever-changing world of business, these capabilities are
incredibly valuable. You need the best information to compete. Use your resources to evaluate and select the high-performance solution that
will provide the most value to your organization. T
Robin Jessani has provided strategic product and marketing direction for the Teradata Warehouse solution for the last 15 years. Currently, in
her role as a senior marketing manager, she focuses on new customer acquisitions and provides guidance to prospective customers during their
decision-making process.
Teradata Magazine-June 2007
|